Last week, I was brought into the middle of a situation with a kid I've never taught. Basically, I was asked to recommend her expulsion from school. Her list of offenses is staggering, and she is out of district. She starts fights constantly.
I was probably being set up when the administator asked me to intervene, because it's not a secret that I have a soft heart and remain idealistic with these kids. They say I believe every kid can be saved; but that's not really true. I've been around long enough to know that they don't all make it. I do believe, however, in trying. And so, I said I want to try to let this kid - this kid on the fast track to expusion and most likely jail - take her class alone in my room, where there is nobody left to fight.
Good luck with that, they said. They warned me that, if I was lucky, she'd just get mad when she was isolated and walk out. She'd probably lose her mind and curse me out. Resource officers could be waiting if I requested them.
I said I did not think that would happen. I think, I said, she'll be really nice and compliant with me.
On Wednesday, I brought her into my class. She was mad. She was not yelling or walking out yet, but she sat silently raging with her head on the desk. She wanted to be in her other class. She did not want to be with me. She promised for the thousandth time that she was not going to fight anymore - that this time she meant it.
I spent most of the period talking to her.
The next day, she came back. I was waiting with Catcher in the Rye. She read the first chapter and we started to discuss it. I asked what her first impression of Holden was.
I think he's mean, she said.
I was caught off-guard. Holden is mean? Holden is so not mean. I asked her why she said she thinks he is mean.
I guess it's the stuff he says.
And, I suppose, he does come across as mean. I told her that she was right, he does seem mean until you get to know him - but that he's not mean. He may act mean, but his heart is not a mean heart; he's just hurt.
So, I re-read the chapter out loud and we discussed it. She wanted to know, if she came back, could we have class like that every day - reading and discussing. I told her we could.
It will take her just eight more weeks to earn the credit. She's months away from graduating if she avoids another expulsion. I can't say what I think will happen; I don't know. I know it's a brutal sytem that does not work for a lot of kids, and that there are so many external factors that come into play that it's impossible to know what will happen to any of the kids I teach. I know I've got former students in college and in jail.
At the end of the period, she was talking about her best friend; she said that her friend was the only person that really understood her.
People say I am mean, she said. But I'm not mean, I'm just hurt.
I nodded.
This is why I teach English.